firmware/docs/printer-replica.md

The printer replica

Everything in tools/replica/printer/ exists to answer one question honestly: would this package brick the machine?

A Debian container with hand-written stand-ins cannot answer it. The stock installer is shell, and shell behaviour is not portable in the ways that matter here — Debian's /bin/sh is dash, which rejects ${file_name:${#start_head}:${version_length}} with Bad substitution, while the printer's busybox accepts it. Get that wrong in either direction and the simulation and the printer disagree about whether an update installs at all.

So the replica runs the printer's own userland.

What it is

work/rootfs/          rootfs.squashfs, extracted from the stock package's
                      kernel component -- the printer's real root filesystem
                      (busybox 1.31.1, glibc 2.33, MIPS32r2 nan2008, mipsel)

tools/replica/ffsim/replica.py starts a privileged container that:

1. registers a binfmt_misc handler so MIPS binaries execute (see below),
2. builds the machine's mount layout,
3. installs the stock FlashForge package with FlashForge's own installer — only when BASE_PKG is set. The bring-up module does not need it, so the MCU gate skips this step,
4. chroots in and runs the test case.

From step 4 onward there is no host shell involved. sh, tar, md5sum, find, cmp and the unTar decryptor are all the printer's binaries, executing under qemu-mipsel (expr and unzip are the printer's too, but are reached only from inside the stock installer, not from any case script).

The mount layout

Copied from the machine (/etc/fstab, /etc/init.d/S09mount_mmc_prog, /etc/init.d/S21mount_mmc_ext4):

path	what it is	mode
/	rootfs.squashfs	read-only
/usr/prog	ext4 usershare partition	rw
/usr/data	ext4 userdata partition	rw
/tmp, /run	tmpfs	rw
/mnt	the USB stick	rw

Root is read-only on purpose. On the printer a write to /bin or /etc silently fails; a mod that depended on one would pass a permissive sandbox and fail on the machine.

/dev is a tmpfs holding null, zero, full, random, urandom, tty, a devpts at pts, a tmpfs at shm, and a regular file for fb0 (the installer does cat start.img > /dev/fb0). /sys is mounted read-only.

The one block device is the USB stick. With USB_STICK=1 the harness formats a FAT filesystem, copies the packages into it, attaches it to a loop device and exposes it as /dev/sda1 — the name app_startup.sh looks for. That is what lets the end-to-end test run the boot script verbatim instead of re-implementing it: the printer mounts the stick itself, globs for its own filename pattern, and decides on its own whether there is an update. Nothing that could reach an eMMC partition (mmcblk*) exists, so a stray write still has nowhere to go.

app_startup.sh mounts the stick with -o,codepage=936,iocharset=utf8. The printer's kernel has nls_cp936 built in; container kernels usually do not, so /bin/mount is wrapped to try the genuine options first and retry without codepage= only if the kernel rejects them. The retry is recorded in /usr/prog/.SIMULATED and in the neutered-calls log the test prints.

The one-byte reason this did not work before

qemu-user-static registers a binfmt matcher for mipsel whose mask requires e_ident[EI_ABIVERSION] — byte 8 of the ELF header — to be 0. Every binary the Ingenic toolchain produced for this printer has 3 there:

00000000: 7f45 4c46 0101 0100 0300 0000 0000 0000  .ELF............
                            ^^ EI_ABIVERSION = 3

So the stock handler never matched, and every attempt to run a printer binary came back exec format error — with qemu installed, registered and enabled. tools/replica/printer/binfmt.sh registers a handler with that byte masked out. Everything else is the stock mipsel matcher.

The handler is registered with the F (fix-binary) flag, so the kernel holds the interpreter open and it resolves inside the chroot without copying qemu into the printer's filesystem.

Getting rid of the stubs entirely

/usr/prog is a factory image: update packages carry only slices of it, and the full thing ships in the factory firmware (see below — it is published). Two things supply it to the replica, and there is no third:

1. PROG_DUMP — a real /usr/prog off a printer, used verbatim:

   ssh root@printer 'tar -cf - /usr/prog' > prog.tar
   # then in test.env:
   PROG_DUMP="/path/to/prog.tar"
   

   With one, nothing below is stubbed: the klipper daemons, nginx, python3, checkEboard and the printer's own OpenSSL 1.0.2d all become genuine, and the -md md5 substitution disappears because the real 1.0.2d binary runs under qemu. This is the single highest-value artefact you can hand the test suite.

2. FlashForge's own installer, run inside the replica, which installs the parts an update package does carry on top of it.

There used to be a third: stubs, for whatever neither of those provided. They are gone. A green run that came from a hand-written python3 and an OpenSSL 3 pretending to be 1.0.2d is reassurance, not evidence — tools/replica/printer/seed-prog.sh now hard-fails when the prog partition is not real.

A full-filesystem factory image works too, and one is published:

https://github.com/ghzserg/FF/releases/download/R/Creator5Pro-factory.tar.xz
md5 d2fdc0e1deb17c41cbb6016d55ab3031   182MB compressed, 828MB extracted

It is the genuine /usr/prog and /usr/data off a Creator 5 Pro — Python-3.8.2, nginx, openssl-1.0.2d, moonraker, qt-4.8.6, ffmpeg-4.0.2, opencv-4.10, the klipper tree, firmwareRes, the stock configs. Point PROG_DUMP (in test.env) at the .tar.xz directly; the replica works out whether an archive is a whole-filesystem image or the contents of /usr/prog and unpacks it accordingly.

With it, the replica decrypts packages using the printer's own OpenSSL 1.0.2d binary under qemu — so the -md md5 packing is verified against the real implementation rather than against an assumption about it.

What is authentic and what is not

/usr/prog on a real printer is the factory image plus every update installed since. The replica is assembled the same way — the published factory image supplies the partition, and FlashForge's own installer lays the update package on top:

• Installed for real, by FlashForge's own run.sh: app_startup.sh, klipper/ (klippy, extras, kinematics, chelper/c_helper.so), start.sh, klipper_pri.sh, unTar, wakeup_level, firmwareExe, passwd, shadow, modules/, PROGRAM/{software,library}/<version>/, plus ffmpeg-402 and the firmwareRes image set from the library component.
• Genuine, from the factory image: everything else on the prog partition — klipperDaemon, moonrakerDaemon, checkEboard, nginx, python3, moonraker, the stock nginx.conf, and the printer's OpenSSL 1.0.2d. (A mod install leaves all of this alone. Its own Moonraker is extracted to /usr/data/anvil/moonraker on the DATA partition and started from there — see how-it-works — so the factory tree here, the interpreter and moonrakerDaemon all stay stock, and moonrakerDaemon is simply never invoked. Nothing the mod installs is written to the prog partition's moonraker/, which is what makes it a useful baseline: case-install.sh asserts this tree is untouched after an install.)
• Not present at all: stubs. Without a real prog partition the replica refuses to start rather than substitute one.
• Neutered, always: insmod, rmmod, modprobe, reboot, poweroff, halt and cmd_mcu. The first six would act on the host kernel; cmd_mcu is called by klipper's start.sh as cmd_mcu write_firmware, and the genuine binary is neutered in place rather than shadowed, so nothing depends on PATH order.

Every one of these is listed inside the replica at /usr/prog/.SIMULATED, so a test can never quietly depend on a stub without it being visible.

The baseline install deliberately skips the kernel-* and control-* components: one rewrites eMMC partitions, the other flashes MCUs over /dev/ttyS*. Neither can do anything useful in a container, and both are destructive if they ever found real hardware.

Why not full-system emulation

The obvious next step would be qemu-system-mipsel booting the printer's own kernel. It does not help. The kernel in the stock package is built for the Ingenic X2000 SoC and there is no QEMU machine for it; booting the userland under qemu-system-mipsel would mean supplying some other mipsel kernel (malta, say), which is no more the printer's kernel than the host's is. What it would cost is a boot cycle per test and a second kernel to maintain.

The install path is file operations and shell, and those run on the printer's own binaries here. The host kernel serves the syscalls; the printer's kernel is 5.6 and the host's is newer, which is a real difference but not one the installer can see. Where it would matter — module loading, MTD writes, MCU serial — the replica refuses to pretend, and those calls are neutered and logged instead.

What it still cannot tell you

• Nothing here drives the screen, the MCUs, the toolchanger or a real print. The replica proves the install is safe and the machine would boot; the hardware procedure in docs/hardware-testing.md is still how you find out whether it prints.
• firmwareExe is a 20MB Qt binary that wants a framebuffer. It is checked for presence, executability and ELF-ness, never run.
• Timing-dependent boot races are not modelled.
• Partition sizes are unbounded unless you set PROG_MB and DATA_MB (in test.env) from what df -h reports on the printer itself. Until then an install that runs the data partition out of space passes here and fails on the machine. The replica says so in /usr/prog/.SIMULATED.

Running it

make rootfs          # once -- extracts rootfs.squashfs from the stock package
make qa-replica      # the replica suite: install, upgrade, boot, supervision
make test-py         # klipper config, and rootfs paths when one is present

make qa-replica does not skip when a stock package is missing: it fails at the point that needs one, with the command that fixes it in the message. There is no flag and nothing for a workflow to remember to set, which is why ALLOW_SKIP is gone entirely. REQUIRE_PRINTER_SIM survives only for the two single-purpose wrappers that can still skip — make rootfs and make boot-screen-sim.